Really 3.5, we need half stars and no I can't round up because I didn't like it as well as the others in the series that I gave 4 stars to. The first one was 5 stars and I keep hoping. I like Remy and I love Marlowe - more Marlowe please! I'm just tired of the angel wars and Heaven & Hell. Just give us Remy and Marlowe with a case on earth.